Besson has cast Milla Jovovich as his Joan. She was his wife at the time they started shooting. They have since split--although he says they would still be together if they could only have made movies 365 days a year, a statement that may provide more insight than he intended. Jovovich, who also starred in Besson's 'The Fifth Element,' is a healthy, cheerful, open-faced 24-year-old actress who seems much too robust and uncomplicated to play Joan.
Friday, November 12, 1999 Milla Jovovich – cool hairdo and all – leads French troops into the battle of Orleans. The Messenger: The Story of Joan of Arc (1999).
The movie is a mess: a gassy costume epic with nobody at the center. So deficient is Besson at suggesting the conscience which rules Joan's actions that the movie even uses another character, the Grand Inquisitor, as a surrogate conscience, and brings in Dustin Hoffman to play it. That Hoffman's performance is the best in the film should have been a nudge to the filmmaker that he could cut back on the extras and the battle scenes and make the movie about--well, about Joan.
Joan of Arc was a naive young French peasant woman, illiterate, who was told by voices that she must go to the aid of her king. France at that time was ill-supplied with kings; the best it could offer was the reluctant Dauphin (John Malkovich), later Charles VII. She informed him her destiny was to lead French troops on the battlefield against the English, who were godless (or foreign, which to the French was a negligible distinction).
Legend has it she ended the siege of Orleans. Legend may be wrong. A new book published in France by the historian Roger Caratini claims 'precious little of what we French have been taught in school about Joan of Arc is true.' He finds scant evidence that Joan did much more than go along for the ride and adds cruelly that she could not have raised the siege of Orleans because the city was never besieged in the first place. Her trial for heresy was not at the hands of the British but under the French Inquisition at the University of Paris, and her greatest crime may have been dressing like a boy and offending the ecclesiastical gender police. Her legend was 'more or less invented' in the 19th century, we learn, as a tonic for emerging French nationalism, which had a 'desperate need for a patriotic mascot.' Of course we do not expect 'The Messenger' to be a revisionist downgrading of the French national heroine, who was burned by a schismatic branch of the church and canonized by Rome five centuries later without having, perhaps, done much to deserve either. We expect a patriotic epic, in which the heroic young woman saves her country but is destroyed by an effete ruler and a lot of grim old clerics. Even if the film is not about a battle of opposing moralities, even if it is not about conscience (as the Dreyer and Bresson films are), it can at least be as much fun as, say, 'Braveheart,' wouldn't you think? No such luck. Besson's film is a thin, uninvolving historical romp in which the only juicy parts are played by supporting characters, such as the Dauphin, made by John Malkovich into a man whose interest in the crown essentially ends with whether it fits. Faye Dunaway has fun as his stepmother, Yolande D'Aragon, who schemes against Joan as any mother would when her son falls under the sway of a girl from the wrong side of the class divide. And Dustin Hoffman is really very good as the Inquisitor, even if his role seems inspired by the desperate need to somehow shoehorn philosophy into the film. I was reminded of the Roger Corman horror picture where holes in the plot were plugged by hiring two bit players and having one ask the other, 'Now explain what all this means.'
Home > UNIVERSITY-PUBLICATIONS > MESSENGER > Vol. 1999 (1999) > Iss. 1
Complete Issue
Artwork
Classic
Keith Cunningham
The Exchange
Tim Hospodar
The Messenger 1999 Cast
Untitled
Craig Bromley
Octopus Tree
Tim Hospodar
Untitled
Jason Gaccione
How About a Box, a Pear, and a Grapefruit
Blythe King
Untitled
Beth Thomas
Hulgate, NJ
Joe Magliaro
Fiction
Smith
David Stanius
Untitled
Glennon Karr
Poetry
Joseph
Sharon Bricker
Epiphany
Christopher Robley
Train #99 (WAS-RIC)
. Anonymous
My Mind's Beauty
Darby Erbaugh
The Messenger 1999 Full Movie
Anticipation
Carrie Kenady
Glorious Restoration
Krysti Sibley
Tonight
Brett A. Morgan
Hunting in Arcadia with my Grandson
Christopher Robley
The Messenger 1999
Untitled
Barrett Emerick
Vowel Song (An Imitation of Rimbaud's Voyelies)
Carrie Kenady
The Messenger 1999 Cast
Schizophrenia -- Welcome to Hillbilly Heaven
James MacCurtain
Restricted Access: Campus only
CREDITS
MESSENGER 1999
- EDITOR
- Tom Williams
- Assistant Editors
- Blythe King
- Joe Magliaro
- STAFF
- Dave Culley
- Laura Nazimek
- Andrew Chiacchierini
- Beth Thomas
- Saadia Iqbal
- Daniel Biegelsen
- Katherine Foret
- Tiffany Pender
- Irene Arce
- Carrie Kenady
- ADVISOR
- Dr. Joe Essid
- UNIVERSITY FACULTY
- Dr. Stephen Addiss
- Dr. Dona Hickey
- Dr. Angela Ball